Use code SIDECHEF for $10 off your first shoppable recipe order.
SideChef
 >  Recipes
 >  Pescatarian Recipes
RECIPE
9 INGREDIENTS4 STEPS5min

Creamy Cookie Butter Cocktail

Creamy Cookie Butter Cocktail is a cozy, full flavor drink that is a must any time of the year. Made with the highly sought-after and addicting cookie butter, Bailey’s Almande, dark rum, vodka, brown sugar, spices, and almond milk, this is the perfect dessert cocktail. Enjoy this cocktail that takes less than 5 minutes to make.
Creamy Cookie Butter Cocktail Recipe | SideChef
Creamy Cookie Butter Cocktail is a cozy, full flavor drink that is a must any time of the year. Made with the highly sought-after and addicting cookie butter, Bailey’s Almande, dark rum, vodka, brown sugar, spices, and almond milk, this is the perfect dessert cocktail. Enjoy this cocktail that takes less than 5 minutes to make.
Chelsea Peachtree
Hi Everyone! I am so happy you are here! My name is Chelsea and I am a recipe developer, food photographer and content creator. My goal is to provide you with simple, straight forward vegan recipes that have normal ingredients you can read.
https://chelseapeachtree.com
Save Time,
Shop Ingredients
Make grocery shopping easy! Add recipes to your cart, review your ingredients and checkout online with Walmart.
Pick Up From
Estimated Total: Estimated Total:
Fulfilled by
Chelsea Peachtree
Hi Everyone! I am so happy you are here! My name is Chelsea and I am a recipe developer, food photographer and content creator. My goal is to provide you with simple, straight forward vegan recipes that have normal ingredients you can read.
https://chelseapeachtree.com
5min
Total Time
$3.71
Cost Per Serving

Ingredients

US / METRIC
Servings:
1
Serves 1
2 Tbsp
Cookie Butter Spread
start with 2 and add to your taste
or Lotus Biscoff Spread
3 fl oz
Bailey's® Almande
0.8 fl oz
0.8 fl oz
Dark Rum
I used Meyer’s Dark Rum
3.5 fl oz
Almond Milk
or Any Plant Based Milk
1 tsp
Brown Sugar
1/4 tsp
Ground Allspice
1/4 tsp
Ground Cinnamon
to taste
Ice
Save Time,
Shop Ingredients
Make grocery shopping easy! Add recipes to your cart, review your ingredients and checkout online with Walmart.
Pick Up From
Estimated Total: Estimated Total:
Fulfilled by

Nutrition Per Serving

VIEW ALL
CALORIES
630
FAT
28.0 g
PROTEIN
4.1 g
CARBS
42.7 g

Author's Notes

I used Bailey’s Almande because it is vegan. If you do not have any issue with regular Baileys, you may use that in place of the vegan version.

Vodka– You cannot taste the vodka in this drink, but if vodka is not your friend, you may leave this ingredient out. It will make the cocktail not as strong though!

Brown Sugar- I have yet to try this drink with regular sugar, so I cannot provide any subs. Do include this ingredient, however, as it aids in amplifying the taste.

Cinnamon and Allspice - These two spices also amplify the taste to ensure it fully tastes like cookie butter. If you do not have one, sub the other in place of it (for example, use 1/2 tsp of cinnamon rather than 1/4 tsp if you do not have allspice).

Cooking Instructions

HIDE IMAGES
Step 1
Melt Cookie Butter Spread (2 Tbsp) in a microwave or stovetop. Start slowly, as it burns easily.
Step 2
Pour melted cookie butter, Bailey's® Almande (3 fl oz) , Vodka (0.8 fl oz) , Dark Rum (0.8 fl oz) , Almond Milk (3.5 fl oz) , Brown Sugar (1 tsp) , Ground Allspice (1/4 tsp) , and Ground Cinnamon (1/4 tsp) into a shaker and shake well. If you do not have a shaker, whisk the mixture in a bowl or place all ingredients into a mason jar, tighten the lid and shake.
Step 3
Add Ice (to taste) to a cup and pour the mixture into the glass. Cheers!
Step 4
Serve immediately. If you must store it, place in the fridge for 30 minutes without ice. Shake well before pouring.
ADD TO PLAN

Rate & Review

Tap to Rate:
Leave a comment
42 Saved
TOP
You're one smart cookie! 🍪
By using this site, you agree to the use of cookies by SideChef and our partners for analytics and personalized content. ACCEPT
Recipe Saved to My Saved Recipes VIEW
Save Time, Shop Ingredients
Love this recipe? Shop what you need with just one click. Get $10 off your first order with code SIDECHEF
Make cooking easy
Discover personalized recipes, organize your meal plans, shop ingredients, and cook with confidence alongside our FREE, step-by-step cooking app.
Nutrition Per Serving
Calories
630
% Daily Value*
Fat
28.0 g
36%
Saturated Fat
12.1 g
60%
Trans Fat
0.0 g
--
Cholesterol
53.3 mg
18%
Carbohydrates
42.7 g
16%
Fiber
0.7 g
2%
Sugars
34.0 g
--
Protein
4.1 g
8%
Sodium
214.8 mg
9%
Vitamin D
1.1 µg
6%
Calcium
221.8 mg
17%
Iron
0.5 mg
3%
Potassium
109.9 mg
2%
Find Nearby Walmart Stores
Enter your zip code to find a Walmart near you.
Sorted by distance from