I used Bailey’s Almande because it is vegan. If you do not have any issue with regular Baileys, you may use that in place of the vegan version.
Vodka– You cannot taste the vodka in this drink, but if vodka is not your friend, you may leave this ingredient out. It will make the cocktail not as strong though!
Brown Sugar- I have yet to try this drink with regular sugar, so I cannot provide any subs. Do include this ingredient, however, as it aids in amplifying the taste.
Cinnamon and Allspice - These two spices also amplify the taste to ensure it fully tastes like cookie butter. If you do not have one, sub the other in place of it (for example, use 1/2 tsp of cinnamon rather than 1/4 tsp if you do not have allspice).