Gluten-Free Black and White Cookie

An iconic New York City cookie goes gluten-free.
Joy Nemerson at SideChef
When I’m not developing recipes or producing SideChef content I explore entomophagy aka I EAT BUGS! I cook “Uncomfortable Comfort Food” -See GetBuggie on IG for more!

Although many rave about New York City’s various regional dishes- cheesecake, pizza, bagels, or corned beef - I was only ever interested in one cookie. This cookie goes by many names- the black and white, half-moon cookie, half-and-half -- depending on where you’re from you call it something different. A traditional version of this cookie has a lemony soft cakey batter base that domes up as it bakes. In most cases, it's the size of your palm and is frosted on one side with thick vanilla and the other with chocolate.

Growing up in New Haven Connecticut the single most exciting journey for me was taking the train from Union Station to Grand Central in New York City. Just getting to Grand Central would have been a thrilling trip, with its incredible architecture, beautiful star covered ceilings, and the vintage ticket booths. But for my family, this station is also home to a tradition that we still carry out to this day. Without fail, every time one of us goes to New York they come bounding in the door with a box full of moon cookies.

As with any New York City Iconic Food, there are disagreements over which institution serves the best moon cookie. Within Grand Central Station, my family’s preferred retailers are Juniors or Zaro’s.

I grew up eating moon cookies year after year, but my consumption was cut short when I turned 16 and acquired a wheat allergy. Suddenly my family tradition was something I could no longer participate in. Over the years we each scoured the country for bakeries that made moon cookies to match my new diet. While I have felt deeply welcomed and comforted by brands like My Dad’s Cookies and Dana’s Bakery there just aren't any in Shanghai, where I live now. Thus, to bring a bite of home to my new life in China, I developed this Black and White Cookie recipe (and I promise Mom, I will bake you a whole box next time I am home).

Please enjoy these soft, gluten-free, and lemony cookies with traditional Vanilla and Chocolate frosting. Let my nostalgia bomb bring some extra joy into your kitchen.

When I’m not developing recipes or producing SideChef content I explore entomophagy aka I EAT BUGS! I cook “Uncomfortable Comfort Food” -See GetBuggie on IG for more!
Sign up for Our Newsletter
Will be used in accordance with our PRIVACY POLICY.
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Meet Belqui of Belqui's Twist
TRIED & TESTED
Mums, Grandmothers, and Pandan Raspberry Cake
HEALTH & WELLNESS
Demystifying the Gluten-Free Diet
LEARN COOK EAT
Your Go-To Apple Cider Guide
TRIED & TESTED
Reimaged Rosh Hashanah Dinner
WHAT'S IN SEASON
What’s in Season in September, and How to Cook It
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
How to Care for Your Dutch Oven
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
Buffalo Chicken Dip: Shareable, Scalable, Delicious
TRIED & TESTED
The Inside Scoop: How to Make Edible Cookie Dough
TRIED & TESTED
Making McDonalds Keto: An Inclusive Filet-O-Fish Sandwich
TRIED & TESTED
Making Auntie Anne Proud: Baking Soda to Butter Baths
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
Plant Based Milk: Five Facts, Five Recipes
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Meet Belqui of Belqui's Twist
Empowering cooks everywhere to always cook from the heart.
TRIED & TESTED
Mums, Grandmothers, and Pandan Raspberry Cake
The best of both worlds; modernizing the traditional Pandan Cake
HEALTH & WELLNESS
Demystifying the Gluten-Free Diet
From celiac disease to gluten intolerance, there are plenty of reasons to learn about where exactly this substance is found and how to better manage your intake!
LEARN COOK EAT
Your Go-To Apple Cider Guide
A delicate blend of sweet and tart, delicious when served hot or cold, apple cider is the perfect versatile fall drink! Here's how to make your own all season long.
TRIED & TESTED
Reimaged Rosh Hashanah Dinner
Rosh Hashanah dinner is a time to come together to celebrate and eat! This recipe is full of meaning and meant to be shared. With the salmon's delicious, gluten allergy-friendly pistachio coating, and a fun twist on an Apple and Honey with a Salad - this dish will be an instant holiday classic.
WHAT'S IN SEASON
What’s in Season in September, and How to Cook It
A list of fruits and vegetables in season in September alongside recipe recommendations.
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
How to Care for Your Dutch Oven
Tips for keeping your dutch oven in tip-top shape and our favorite recipes to make in them.
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
Buffalo Chicken Dip: Shareable, Scalable, Delicious
The beloved dish from Buffalo, NY evolves into a dip, and now transforms into the perfect sliders.
TRIED & TESTED
The Inside Scoop: How to Make Edible Cookie Dough
A look inside my head at the recipe development behind the pantry perfect (and gluten free!) dessert.
TRIED & TESTED
Making McDonalds Keto: An Inclusive Filet-O-Fish Sandwich
On recreating McDonald's iconic Fish Filet sandwich
TRIED & TESTED
Making Auntie Anne Proud: Baking Soda to Butter Baths
Making Auntie Anne's soft pretzels can be pretty hard. My journey from basic mall rat to an at-home culinary scientist.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
Plant Based Milk: Five Facts, Five Recipes
In honor of World Plant Milk Day, we're sharing some knowledge around milk alternatives and some recipes to make your own at home.
You're one smart cookie! 🍪
By using this site, you agree to the use of cookies by SideChef and our partners for analytics and personalized content. ACCEPT
SideChef: 18k Recipes, Meal Planner, Grocery List, Personalization
INSTALL APP
Make cooking easy
Discover personalized recipes, organize your meal plans, shop ingredients, and cook with confidence alongside our FREE, step-by-step cooking app.