Making Auntie Anne Proud: Baking Soda to Butter Baths

Making Auntie Anne's soft pretzels can be pretty hard. My journey from basic mall rat to an at-home culinary scientist.
Joy Nemerson at SideChef
When I’m not developing recipes or producing SideChef content I explore entomophagy aka I EAT BUGS! I cook “Uncomfortable Comfort Food” -See GetBuggie on IG for more!

Perfectly waxed floors, glossy window displays, and the blank faces of mannequins all brought to life by the smell of glorious, salty, butter. If playgrounds are the social meeting place for elementary school, the mall was my middle school equivalent. Movies, faux makeovers, people watching - but most of all - soft pretzel nuggets and lemonade from Auntie Anne’s (often followed by secretly wiping off grease-coated fingers before slipping into photo booths, or stumbling into shops to test driv Heelys).

Soft pretzels from the mall are sadly a thing of my past (I'm gluten-free by necessity these days). Powered by strong sensory memories, I set out to recreate the prized pretzel, gluten-free, from the SideChef studio kitchen. As it turns out, pretzels are pretty complex-chemically speaking! They require a little more commitment than other food court favorites I've attempted in the past - a classic Mrs. Fields cookie or Panda Express orange chicken. The crux of this pretzel recipe lies within the crust.

Achieving a crunchy exterior and soft interior relies on a chemical reaction that occurs when pretzel dough is bathed in a basic solution of boiling water and baking soda prior to being baked. Of course, when I say basic I don’t mean - those shoes are so basic - I mean that on a pH scale, the solution's pH is greater than 7. In case you forgot your 10th-grade science, pH is a measure of how acidic or basic water is and it ranges from 0 - 14. A pH of less than 7 indicates acidity, whereas a pH of greater than 7 indicates a base (7 is neutral). Creating your own basic solution is nothing to stress about. Although traditional pretzel recipes call for making your basic solution with lye, a much safer, and more accessible option, is baking soda.

But what does the bath really do? Great question! The reasoning behind this method is similar to why you bathe bagels. Boiling the dough allows the baking soda to assist in the activation of browning during the bake that follows. Essentially, when baked, the development of the crust and color happens much quicker, without compromising the soft interior. Without the bath to achieve the correct level of crust, you risk overbaking and destroying any chances at a chewy, soft center. It's what's on the inside that counts, right?

Outside of the all-important bath, there are a few other key elements that make this recipe work really well. I have had some bad yeast experiences, so I always prefer to bloom yeast in warm (110 F) water or milk before incorporating to ensure that my yeast is alive, awake, and ready to bake. As I was trying to create the soft pillowy texture of the Auntie Anne's I remember so well, I decided to bloom the yeast in milk. In gluten-free baking, it's important to build proteins in the dough to replace gluten and milk does that better in this particular recipe. The last, but almost more crucial choice, was the melted butter bath at the end of this recipe that truly transported me right back to the food court. Now you can make your very own iconic Auntie Annie Pretzels, gluten-free, regardless of malls being open or closed.

When I’m not developing recipes or producing SideChef content I explore entomophagy aka I EAT BUGS! I cook “Uncomfortable Comfort Food” -See GetBuggie on IG for more!
Sign up for Our Newsletter
Will be used in accordance with our PRIVACY POLICY.
TRIED & TESTED
Weeknight Dinner Winner - Carbonara, Simplified
LEARN COOK EAT
Three Reasons Why We are Excited about Walmart+
TRIED & TESTED
Why You Should Definitely Make Fresh Pasta This Weekend
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Blogger Spotlight: Lemons and Basil
CULTURE
How Omakase Works
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Meet Belqui of Belqui's Twist
HEALTH & WELLNESS
Demystifying the Gluten-Free Diet
LEARN COOK EAT
Your Go-To Apple Cider Guide
TRIED & TESTED
Reimaged Rosh Hashanah Dinner
WHAT'S IN SEASON
What’s in Season in September, and How to Cook It
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
How to Care for Your Dutch Oven
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
Buffalo Chicken Dip: Shareable, Scalable, Delicious
TRIED & TESTED
Weeknight Dinner Winner - Carbonara, Simplified
Two sentences at the top: Weeknight Carbonara is THE answer to getting dinner on the table in under 20 minutes.
LEARN COOK EAT
Three Reasons Why We are Excited about Walmart+
One of our favorite grocers just released a service to make all of our lives easier and we couldn't be happier about it.
TRIED & TESTED
Why You Should Definitely Make Fresh Pasta This Weekend
Make pasta without a pasta machine - free yourself from another single-use appliance!
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Blogger Spotlight: Lemons and Basil
The mastermind behind Lemons and Basil, Kaylee Pauley, shares her love for healthy food and living, along with a few of her favorite recipes!
CULTURE
How Omakase Works
You may have heard the word “omakase” tossed around as this cultural trend sweeps through the sushi bars of America--but what does it mean, and how does it work? We're here to explain!
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Meet Belqui of Belqui's Twist
Empowering cooks everywhere to always cook from the heart.
HEALTH & WELLNESS
Demystifying the Gluten-Free Diet
From celiac disease to gluten intolerance, there are plenty of reasons to learn about where exactly this substance is found and how to better manage your intake!
LEARN COOK EAT
Your Go-To Apple Cider Guide
A delicate blend of sweet and tart, delicious when served hot or cold, apple cider is the perfect versatile fall drink! Here's how to make your own all season long.
TRIED & TESTED
Reimaged Rosh Hashanah Dinner
Rosh Hashanah dinner is a time to come together to celebrate and eat! This recipe is full of meaning and meant to be shared. With the salmon's delicious, gluten allergy-friendly pistachio coating, and a fun twist on an Apple and Honey with a Salad - this dish will be an instant holiday classic.
WHAT'S IN SEASON
What’s in Season in September, and How to Cook It
A list of fruits and vegetables in season in September alongside recipe recommendations.
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
How to Care for Your Dutch Oven
Tips for keeping your dutch oven in tip-top shape and our favorite recipes to make in them.
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
Buffalo Chicken Dip: Shareable, Scalable, Delicious
The beloved dish from Buffalo, NY evolves into a dip, and now transforms into the perfect sliders.
You're one smart cookie! 🍪
By using this site, you agree to the use of cookies by SideChef and our partners for analytics and personalized content. ACCEPT
SideChef: 18k Recipes, Meal Planner, Grocery List, Personalization
INSTALL APP
Make cooking easy
Discover personalized recipes, organize your meal plans, shop ingredients, and cook with confidence alongside our FREE, step-by-step cooking app.