Use code SIDECHEF for $10 off your first shoppable recipe order.

Here are the Winners of Our Mac and Cheese Taste-Off

Extra cheese, please! In our first culinary partner throwdown, Marley’s Menu’s classic mac and cheese recipe gets high honors
Kate Ricard at SideChef
Content Partnerships Manager and unofficial SideChef recipe tester. I love talking to people for a living.
Love This Recipe?
Kate Ricard at SideChef
Content Partnerships Manager and unofficial SideChef recipe tester. I love talking to people for a living.

This summer’s most epic battle was fought and won at the SideChef kitchen arena. Three mac and cheese recipes, chosen from a pool of partner submissions, were prepped, cooked, and judged in our SideChef’s first ever recipe throwdown.

After careful deliberation by SideChef’s in-house personalities (IHPs), these recipes were chosen to take part in the competition: Chelsea Peach Tree’s Buffalo Cauliflower Vegan Mac and Cheese, Throwdown Kitchen’s Noodles Mac and Cheese (But Better), and Marley’s Menu’s Indulgent Mac N Cheese.

Participating recipes were prepared and cooked according to the recipe instructions and judged based on these factors: Taste (40%), Texture (30%), Replicability (20%), and Uniqueness (10%).

(L-R): Tina shows off her dish to judges Whitney, Igor, and Camila

Here are the winners and the SideChef cooks who represented them.

3rd - Chelsea PeachTree’s Buffalo Cauliflower Vegan Mac and Cheese

Mildly spicy and loaded with cauliflower, this mac and cheese has a distinct kick

Taking less than 30 minutes from actual prep to service, Chelsea’s buffalo cauliflower vegan mac and cheese recipe was easy to replicate and packed a sharp and powerful punch on the palate.

Representing Chelsea is Joy, SideChef’s former IHP and Key Account Manager

Try your hand at vegan mac and cheese by following the original recipe from Chelsea Peach Tree below.

2nd - Throwdown Kitchen’s Mac and Cheese

Throwdown Kitchen’s mac and cheese recipe is undeniably cheesy in the best way

With three kinds of cheese AND evaporated milk, John of Throwdown Kitchen’s take on mac and cheese is one sent from the dairy gods. A copycat version of Noodles & Company’s macaroni and cheese, this recipe is rich, creamy, and tastes like your childhood.

Tina, SideChef’s newest IHP, cubed, grated, and whisked her way to the finals

Have an extra-cheesy meal by recreating John’s recipe below.

1st - Marley’s Menu’s Cheesy Indulgent Mac N Cheese

Sometimes you can’t just beat the classics! Marley’s winning recipe is a solid 10/10

The winner of our first taste-off is designed to make the kid in you rejoice. Marley’s mac and cheese recipe is extra creamy, but firm, and packs just the right amount of indulgence to make this meal into your new weeknight classic.

(L-R): Sandie and Lauren pose with the winning recipe

Be a winner in your circle and make Marley’s original recipe below.

EASYPEANUT-FREE

Cheesy Indulgent Mac-n-Cheese

Marley's Menu

Winners of the SideChef’s first taste-off get Walmart gift cards, and their own Winners’ Badges. Thank you to everyone who submitted their recipes and see you at the next taste-off!

Sign Up for the SideChef
Newsletter
Get weekly recipes, grocery shopping, meal planning, and home-cooking inspiration sent straight in your inbox
Will be used in accordance with our PRIVACY POLICY.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
The Breakfast Toast We Love the Most: Jam, Jelly, and Joy
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
A to Z Guide to Confusing Keto Friendly Ingredients Part 2
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Blogger Spotlight: Nick Evans of Macheesmo
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
New: Plan Better, Waste Less
LEARN COOK EAT
Your Ultimate Guide to Thanksgiving Side Dishes
TIPS & TRICKS
7 Best Ways to Use Your Leftover Jam
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
The Great Cheese Dip War
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
A Dip Night With Friends - Your Next Level Potluck
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
How I Made Taco Bell’s Crunchwrap Supreme at Home
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
What Could Mess Up a Perfect Potluck Party and How to Prevent It
WHAT'S IN SEASON
What’s in Season in September, and How to Cook It
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
The Tremendous Tale of Taco Tuesday: Trademarks, Trends, and Tribulations
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
The Breakfast Toast We Love the Most: Jam, Jelly, and Joy
The ultimate comforting breakfast we all love. Toast and jelly or jam or preserves, and maybe add something extra? Let's keep it sweet and not too healthy sometimes! Jam (or jelly) up your breakfast toast, and keep the eggs and avocados out of it for once.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
A to Z Guide to Confusing Keto Friendly Ingredients Part 2
All the Keto food and cooking-related words you have seen or heard but didn’t understand (or maybe it’s just me). This guide will help you navigate through the fascinating world of trendy low-carb Keto recipes and foods. Dive in!
CULINARY PARTNER FEATURE
Blogger Spotlight: Nick Evans of Macheesmo
Meet Nick Evans, the creator of Macheesmo - the place where you can easily learn how to cook with confidence. Find out why you should put down the menu and pick up the spatulas, and the key to loving your leftovers!
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
New: Plan Better, Waste Less
AI-powered hands-on approach to reducing any food waste in your household. Get personalized recipe ideas and meal plans to use up everything you have in your grocery cart. Plan with ease, waste nothing, become a part of a solution for the global food waste problem.
LEARN COOK EAT
Your Ultimate Guide to Thanksgiving Side Dishes
Thanksgiving is one of the holidays we can't help but associate with food, family, and friends. If you agree that the key to a successful Thanksgiving dinner is choosing the suitable side dishes, then this article will help you decide what sides to cook this year. And how to make this Thanksgiving feast perfect precisely for you and your family.
TIPS & TRICKS
7 Best Ways to Use Your Leftover Jam
So you’re cleaning out the fridge, and you’re tired of PB&J, and you have a little bit of jam left in the jar, and you’re thinking, “What can I do with this?”
FOOD FOR THOUGHT
The Great Cheese Dip War
The one truly important debate that needed exploring and everything you will ever need to know about cheese dips… or is it queso? Let’s dive in!
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
A Dip Night With Friends - Your Next Level Potluck
It is time you hosted the most ultimate potluck party, a.k.a a night of dips with friends. Just dips, no salads or mains. You must start planning one now, and this collection of every dip recipe idea possible will make your planning process quick and easy.
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
How I Made Taco Bell’s Crunchwrap Supreme at Home
Bring the drive-thru to your kitchen with this customizable copycat of a Taco Bell classic. Loaded with seasoned ground beef, nacho cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, and sour cream it is worth every calorie!
CELEBRATE, HOST, ENTERTAIN
What Could Mess Up a Perfect Potluck Party and How to Prevent It
Whether you’re throwing a potluck for friends at your house or going to attend one as a guest, or maybe your office is having a potluck-style holiday celebration, it’s really easy to get stressed about making a good impression. Here’s your essential list for everything that could go wrong, all the do’s and don’ts, ideas, and more.
WHAT'S IN SEASON
What’s in Season in September, and How to Cook It
A list of fruits and vegetables in season in September alongside recipe recommendations.
WHAT TO READ THIS WEEK
The Tremendous Tale of Taco Tuesday: Trademarks, Trends, and Tribulations
Have you ever wondered why we all know to look for the best Taco Tuesday deals? Or why it’s a thing to make tacos for Tuesday dinner? Why is it Taco Tuesday and not Thursday? What does Lebron James have to do with tacos? And who invented the Taco Tuesday tradition we all enjoy? Get ready for a crazy story.
You're one smart cookie! 🍪
By using this site, you agree to the use of cookies by SideChef and our partners for analytics and personalized content. ACCEPT
SideChef: 18k Recipes, Meal Planner, Grocery List, Personalization
INSTALL APP
Make cooking easy
Discover personalized recipes, organize your meal plans, shop ingredients, and cook with confidence alongside our FREE, step-by-step cooking app.